Herbert Marcuse - The End of Utopia
Wednesday, June 30, 2010
Decibel Protection For Shooting
AUTHOR: Herbert Marcuse
TITLE: The End of Utopia
EDITORIAL: Metro, SA (First Edition)
YEAR: 1986
PAGES: 180
TRANSLATION: Manuel Sacristán
RANK: 6 / 10
The collapse of the great political and ideological discourse is revealed, according to some theorists, as a fundamental feature of contemporary society. For them, within the current state of capitalism, the stories that led resistance movements throughout the twentieth century, specifically focusing on Marxism, not only have become obsolete due to the low development of his thought, but even today, are seen as dangers and freedoms of citizens and democracy of nations.For Alejandro Jiménez
With this key can be analyzed much of the cutting-edge ideas, even if they continue to oppose the hegemonic system, give up-some more than others-a Marxist interpretation of society. Thus, leaving aside notions of class or alienation and aim for a less ideological language, but sometimes describe the same objective phenomena, those ideas intended to overcome the limitations of Marx's thought has in our time y, sobretodo, escapar un poco del fantasma de los regímenes socialistas y la declarada lucha mediática contra la izquierda.
De este modo, para los desencantados del socialismo, para la gran masa inconciente que es víctima de la propaganda pro-capitalista y, obviamente, para la derecha, un título como E l Final de la Utopía , supondría la rendición definitiva del marxismo, algo así como la declaración de no poder llevar a cabo su proyecto político. Lamentablemente para ellos, El Final de la Utopía no representa para Herbert Marcuse (1898-1979) una derrota, sino, por el contrario, la certidumbre de haber entrado por primera vez en history, the moment it is really possible the advent of a free society:
"The development of productive forces has reached a level that at present the idea of \u200b\u200beradicating hunger and misery in the world is not no utopian dream. As it is not thinking that can transform the nature of alienated labor in truly creative and joyful work. Or you can build a non-repressive civilization. Hence, then, 'The End of Utopia', in the sense that 'the new possibilities of human society and its surroundings so no longer conceivable as a continuation of the old, can not be represented in the same historical continuum , but presuppose a break precisely in the historical continuum, assume the qualitative difference between a free society and the current non-free societies, the difference that, according to Marx, makes the whole story takes place, the prehistory of humanity '"(Page . IV)As you see, and this despite the pessimism which has always been attributed to Herbert Marcuse, this book-in which, the interventions made by the German philosopher at the Free University of Berlin in July 1967 - search , first, examine the conditions more characteristic of late capitalism, work the author had undertaken in Eros and Civilization (1955) and One-Dimensional Man (1964), but also on the other hand, relocating the role of Marxism in the contemporary political landscape, showing how, beyond that which was horrific page Stalinism and the increasing distortion of reality that promotes capitalist system, Marx's utopia can only claim the freedom and lives of human beings.
is not an exhaustive analysis on the contrary, and Hansmartin Kurnitzky Horst Kuhn, publishers of the text, omitting important parts, prioritizing dialogue and the questions raised from the speeches of Marcuse. In this sense, the four parts the book is primarily a construction voices between the philosopher and the academic population of the University. This does not mean not affected by the level above argumentation that characterizes not only to Marcuse, but all the figures of the Frankfurt School, Horkheimer, Adorno, or Habermas, "On the contrary, the same criticism of his position, force Marcuse page after page, to point out examples, to contrast, and even recognize theoretical gaps.
Questions open many horizons and not take the time to reflect on each of them with depth would be needed, that's the main drawback of the book, but all Moreover, it is a guiding volume and very lucid in its assessments. Should be noted, moreover, that Marcuse was received in Berlin by students as the main integrator of thought, and that what makes the discussions that took place there in 1967, his visit to the city where he lived and worked in , but of which he was exiled under the Nazis, have some foreboding against what happened in Paris a year later.
The end of utopia
Marcuse's book is divided into four parts, the first of which is the title of the work. In it the author explains the reasons why you think that we are at a historic moment where it is possible to convert the utopia of Marxism in fact. Her dissertation is based on two premises: 1. any conversion of natural and technical environment is a real possibility in history and 2. the ongoing development of our civilization can, given their economic and scientific levels, seek to achieve a free society.
In other words, the elimination of alienated labor, the repressive practices, poverty and hunger, all aspects which continue to be players in the world are, in our time, we talked for about five decades over here, 'items could be removed from a historic break with capitalism, economic system that holds and therefore the main obstacle for transformation. Marcuse believes that there are two types of impediments that can arise for the realization of a utopia, or that the project openly manifest contradiction with biological or scientific laws, or that subjective and objective factors oppose it.
is clear that there is no scientific or biological law that runs counter to a free society, then Marcuse finds no obstacles of this kind of Marxism. On the contrary, it discovers subjective factors (immaturity, unconsciousness) and objectives (manipulation, false comfort) that away the event of a new world. But even if these forces mobilized all its power "against its own possibility of liberation", is obviously not thereby destroy the realizability of utopia per se. For this reason, Marcuse believed that the main task of socialism-as a promoter of Marxian ideas, is to highlight the dark forces that compel us to reproduce the repression in our own (subjective level) and, likewise, contribute to the breakdown historical capitalism, the only way to achieve a free society. Specifically it is:
1. Appealing to a new set of needs, substantial biological, vital to the man who permitan reducir la actualización en nuestra existencia de necesidades superpuestas como la compra o la esclavitud tecnológica.
2. Descapitalizar la industrialización y la tecnificación, esto es, retrotraer el sentido liberador de la técnica y la industria, rompiendo con las prácticas que nos puedan convertir en esclavos de ellas.
3. Suscitar cualidades estético-eróticas que generen espacios de libertad; por ejemplo, vinculando técnica y arte, trabajo y juego o creación, descanso y felicidad, intimidad y conocimiento.
4. Luchar en dos frentes: uno subjetivo, primordialmente en lo que respecta a la liberación de la conciencia de su manipulación media and other objective, which is to organize, resist and cracking via intra-and extra-institutional capitalism.
Both rich and poor societies should unite under these goals for each individual nuances behave: for the former, the transformation of the will, ie his mind to feel identified with the problems revealed in other more struggles and common enemies, and for the second, the liberation from neo-colonial. Always keep in mind, and this Marcuse insists, that all those who benefit from some form of status-quo , are mobilized in a way exactly opposite, sometimes relying in the power of violence and, therefore, must take a bold position that may lead us to engage in violence at any time.
The problem of violence in opposition
According to a central idea that deals with the opposition should not be construed otherwise than an open, global struggle, Herbert Marcuse outlines some points which could constitute be a New Left in the world. First, it is no longer an orthodox Marxist movement because, without abandoning the classical foundations of Marx, are recognized elements urging renewed scrutiny: the art information tools, the nuclear danger, and so on. Second, no believes that the working class is the only revolutionary hub and it gives counter-hegemonic potential residual groups and class enclaves. And third, find new integration scenarios around spokespersons art and literature, not directly related to political work.
In his view, the New Left is mostly made up what he called the under-privileged , or ethnic and racial minorities who are seen as second-class citizens in the metropolis and on the other hand, privileged "whose conscience and whose instinct break the social direction or achieve escape from it" ie, the class still engaged in production-only extended to the level of technicians and specialists, and also college students. The intellectual resistance to Marcuse is not in itself a revolutionary force, primarily because few times facing material actions, and its language and concerns are far from the least advantaged.
In any case, the New Left should not lose sight that you can only talk of total revolution when: 1. integrate the struggles and interests of the First and Third Worlds, 2. recover the moral and humanitarian arguments, not the way of false ideology, but as a central social forces of Marxism, 3. be displayed inherent contradictions of capitalism, such as automation of labor and repression to be paid for the wealth they have, 4. Fascism is understood that a practice can be explicitly violent, but also a tendency to decrease progressively and the democratic spaces of a society [1], and 5. to avoid the "stubborn" and centralizing interests who believe in the revolutionary discourse [2].
But back to the same point, namely that the path that should open the New Left to make utopia into reality, just rears its head faced the violence of capitalism. It should be emphasized that, when speaking of violence , Marcuse assumes a double significance: revolutionary violence or repressive violence. Never mind that these are two actions that lead to violent or symbolic power, there is a clear distinction between the two: while the revolutionary violence is transcending in the sense that it seeks a free society that no longer needed more intimidation The repressive violence only seeks the subjugation and homogenization of the citizens, therefore, is violence that goes beyond any point and unjustifiable.
Marcuse has no problem to ensure that, under certain circumstances of the revolutionary struggle, it is necessary to act violently. There are times, says, in which it is intolerable suppression of capitalism, for example, in cities, at the hands of discrimination, subjugation or class, but also in a broader context, the neo-colonialism, exploitation or landowner. If you run out of institutional channels, if you have never been feasible to use, you can not condemn civil disobedience or the organization of popular hosts.
However, there are several things that need to be qualified in its conception. On the one hand, Marcuse's vision is almost devoid of moral consideration, this aspect was the thorn in the side of Sartre, who could not know to what extent was a legitimate one adveno company had from the death and violence against their fellow [3]. Secondly, and as is clear from some critical interventions that are made, the author also explores ways non-violent opposition, which, however, were anti-violent and revolutionary, and this in spite of how much has come from bastions of art. Finally, Marcuse forget the danger that can lead to a legitimization of violence, especially for minorities who, by virtue of being neglected and powerless, they could appeal without resentment to crime.
But to his credit, Marcuse distinguishes two other points very well. First, the right-violent resistance or not, is not an exclusive attribute of a class, but is based on a universal requirement to suppress the exploitation and oppression of human beings. And second, that reflection on the role of violence in the revolution, must also pass the question of its degeneration into cruelty or terror, the situation of Stalin, the excesses of China and others are there to show how memory how violence that could be justified at the time to leave a castrating regime ended in a condition of support for the new order:
"... hatred against exploitation and oppression is itself a human element and humanist. For Moreover, there is no doubt that in the course of the revolutionary movement produces hatred, without which there can be no revolution and no release. Anything as outrageous as the loving preaching 'love your enemies' in a world in which hatred is actually fully institutionalized. Of course, in the course of the revolutionary movement itself that hatred can lead to cruelty, brutality and terror. The boundary between the one and the other is distressingly fluid. The only thing I can say is that part of our task is to avoid such a mutation to the extent possible, that is, to show the brutality and cruelty necessarily belong to the system of repression and liberation struggle mutation do not need that hate brutality and cruelty "(p. 41)Moral and political affluent society
However, in addition to a violent system, the realization of a free society against another impediment faced by its features, is even more complex: the capitalist moral misleading. Indeed, beyond that capitalism has left behind corpses, exploitation and maladjusted image of reality, has also been expanding its inventory of achievement: poverty has been reduced to levels undreamed of back in the era of industrialization has possible comforts and freedoms Many individual citizens, has sophisticated technology tools and information, and so on.
These achievements weigh in convincing an individual of his place in society can not think of it as free subject, but, quite the contrary, his life is packaged within the guidelines of well-being, freedom development and misleading. The man who listens to his work in the office does not belong, that his life is perfectly substitutable for that of any other, and that public opinion is not nothing but a media setting, believes that attempts embaucársele, because what he knows -your car, your home, June holiday, it seems the reality in perspective. He does not understand how I could be in the middle of a fabric of simulations without having learned in advance.
Well, this is another big obstacle to the socialist utopia: the power of the system about the citizen, not only do not understand, but up spears to defend when attacked estimate. Marcuse believes that confidence in a set of fair values, such as freedom, justice and dignity, is the vehicle for dealing with this embarrassing mismatch of the objective. Everyone who comes to understand the horizon of these values \u200b\u200bcan not confront him for less than the system that tries to suppress them. And is that many of the same achievements of capitalism are now endangered and their clarification is the first step to get closer to a classless society.
what notes Herbert Marcuse is that the existence of certain privileges in capitalism, the comforts and advantages it has given to some results in the misery of so many, while a dozen parties wasted their money on useless or a afternoon of shopping, hundreds of human beings struggling for survival. That time of 67, for example, showed how horrible the way he spoke on the radio the death toll in Vietnam, severed by napalm, peasants who defended their land from the onslaught of imperialism, and how they were held as a of national victory, as a reason to Yankee pride.
Then, the achievements of capitalism are just a palliative to their own misery and historically shown interest buried. Many participants in the presentations of Marcuse, provides examples of policies that promote capitalism: a hypocrite when it comes to their cross to either side of the Atlantic, manipulative when your goal is convinced of the legitimacy of their crimes to their fellow citizens, repressive to manifest any outbreak of insubordination or discomfort, systematic enforcement of secret plans and, of course, be unconscionable to the maintenance of their trade and economic policy.
Vietnam. The Third World and the opposition in the metropolis
In Third World countries, witnessing firsthand the fierce way in which capitalism, headed by the United States, has been exploited for centuries our land, distributing them as best you think, and allying with the oligarchy, the certainty of the problems of this system is also seriously crossed by public violence and manipulation of reality. The last chapter of The End of Utopia is dedicated to reflection on some of the features that the revolution in these countries and the spots which can be built to a common struggle with industrialized societies.
Perhaps the most striking feature to understand the issue of capitalism in poor countries is the multiplicity of mechanisms that have affected violence against them. have witnessed military violence , for example, when capitalist nations have supported coups illegitimate, or have provided weapons to repressive governments and anti-democratic, but also has been a historical constant the economic violence: the entire Third world lacks a fully developed capitalism, industrialization is a process means, and does not even have-a centuries away from European bourgeoisie, his own national bourgeoisie, at least not a conscious of the importance of economic nationalization and these factors have led to conceive the capitalist countries as centers for poor nations to exploit raw materials or finished consumer goods, but not as allies for the common advancement or true financial partners. As noted by Bahman Nirumand:
"Facing the open door policy practiced by the government of the country behind that of foreign goods, building a solid key industry in the long run is essential to any capitalist economy. But the industry would be contradiction with the old imperialist objectives, ownership of raw materials, since building a solid key industry a great part at least of those raw materials would go to the domestic industry, "and the objectives of neocolonialism, which lose a market hitherto safe for heavy industrial products, and later he would meet a heightened competition in the field of processing industry "(pp. 161-162)capitalism and imperialism are two realities that are unified within violence. Against this, Herbert Marcuse shares the idea of \u200b\u200bthinking is outrageous that the strategic alliance that is woven between operators national capitalists and landlords. As land in poor countries belong only to a few families, the farm is easily converted into a "national policy" that brings benefits only to those families of landowners and the economy of the capitalist countries, but never for the bulk of population, too unconscious and tangled in their "own" issues.
The guerrillas, the product of this situation, is seen by Marcuse as an inevitable result: if in the Third World is a full industrialization, as the production base remains in the field, the main revolutionary force must necessarily be expected the peasantry. This can be easily traced in history, from the mid-twentieth century, in countries like Guatemala, Colombia or Bolivia, where the guerrillas are primarily farmers weary of exploitation. There is a constant error, however, the consolidation of a larger movement, and it is these countries that contact between peasant guerrillas, intellectuals and workers and trade union base is almost nil.
In Colombia, for example, where a guerrilla means, in recent years, both as a "terrorist" or "murderer" urban resistance forces do not want to establish any links with armed groups; prefer to continue with a lackluster fight, but institutional. Not so, Marcuse, who endorses the insurrectionary organizations and even accept their violence as a necessary mechanism of manifestation. Personally I one, like him, despite how dangerous it can be a statement of this kind in our country, supporting a guerrilla group, able to confront the power of the landlords, and to find cooperative ties in universities, unions, workers unions and others. ___________________
The End of Utopia is a call to revolt. We must not let go of the institutional road map, it is part of our objective reality, but we must not contradict other forms of resistance, violent or not, for exploiting the big mouth of capitalism all virtues misleading. The horizon is open, and utopia yet to materialize.
NOTES:
[1] In Latin America, especially in countries with right-wing governments like Colombia, is considered fascism as a European experience or, at best, as a national reality and overcome. The media, mainly responsible for this misrepresentation does not understand the true nature of fascism that is clear from the statement of Marcuse, who literally says, " mass base for the rise of fascism does not have to be that after an economic crisis the masses should be thrown into the street and practice fascist violence and may also be that the masses more and more actively support a trend that is undermining the field game remaining in democracy, limiting and gradually weakening the opposition "(see pg. 77). This can be seen as disturbing the current situation our country is about to begin a new presidential term with the power of the media, economic and political, will focus on a single person who owns, at the same time, major emporiums of these classes: -Weather and a television channel that is coming-a billionaire family, and the presidency of the republic. There is no guarantee, as has been happening to the discourse of "democratic security" that any attempt of resistance that seek out the thought of Santos, is immediately branded as terrorism: the possibilities of opposition in Colombia have begun a chapter perhaps more disastrous than the last eight years.
[2] Here there seems to be a contradiction in the thinking of Herbert Marcuse, and the worrying thing is that it will never be clarified. On the one hand, the philosopher always encourages a claim the role of ethnic minorities in cities, and urged the Socialists to recognize them as revolutionary virtues beyond that whether or not the production system. However, Marcuse says that talking to those who do not share the views of Marxism is "wasting the time and energy", then it is best to focus on the social strata which can be a real job. But this split raises the question: what if the minority who try to adhere to the revolutionary struggle does not share the tenets of Marxism? "It would be wasting the time trying to show his own condition? For others, there is something surprising in the thought Marcuse, and is almost completely forgotten to call its own name other forces such estimable for a revolution: the prostitutes, homosexuals, transsexuals, drug addicts, the sub-cultures of resistance music, among others. These groups do you feel the contradictions of the capitalist system, just never have come to have a place of importance in seeking to promote the intellectual demands.
[3] This ethical dilemma was a constant in the political thought of Jean-Paul Sartre. The French philosopher examine not only from the plane of its justification revolutionary study can be found on pages memorable About 68 , but also from the point of view of repressive violence during the Nazi occupation of France. In The Republic of Silence, for example, Sartre was asked whether the fact that a Communist to speak at a Nazi-sponsored torture could become a way of legitimizing this act of violence, that is, if talking about plans implicitly resistance also was not saying "what I say, worth the violent system you use to make me confess."
Subscribe to entries
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment