Sunday, May 23, 2010

What's The Airbreak In Fsx

Roger Garaudy - Questions to Jean-Paul Sartre



AUTHOR: Roger Garaudy
TITLE: Questions to Jean-Paul Sartre
EDITORIAL: Procyon, SA (First Edition)
YEAR: 1964
PAGES: 112
TRANSLATION: Hector P. Agosti
RANK: 5 / 10



For Alejandro Jiménez

-publication in 1960 - of Critique of Dialectical Reason meant for Sartre the resurgence of the controversy about his philosophical stance and politics. If already at the time of his phenomenological work was tried as a nihilist, and later, as unpatriotic for his defense of the Algerian FLN, there is also another critical move, belonging almost entirely to orthodox Marxism, which since the mid-fifties found in the figure of an enemy French thinker of his doctrine, since, although the left, the way proposed by Sartre for the interpretation of historical events based on assumptions that the statute substantially redefined classic Marx.

There is something that still can not bear the communist dogmatism, and it is precisely the construction of that bridge Sartre proposed between socialism and existentialism in a book like the Critical that for certain Marxist, has the look of a true anti- Capital. From "ignorant" to "bourgeois", one by one dropped on the back of the author the most degrading epithets, many of them based on a simple dislike, not understanding the theories that made Sartre motivated by what he considered emergency work for the left: the update of Marxist thought which followed to the letter, then reached the limits of deification.

Well, that set refutations caused by the ideas of Critique of Dialectical Reason this text is part of Roger Garaudy (1913 -), entitled Q uestions Jean-Paul Sartre (1964). This is a book in which the language of analysis is often confused with that of the rant, why the reader has the feeling of being at a test that valid and universal for all budgets. Indeed, to take a look at the biography of Garaudy we find that not only was one of the most tenacious defenders of Stalinism within France, but also a fundamentalist can prove strong as they move from Catholicism to Islam.

If a militant is influenced to the point of not recognizing the tyranny of their leader, and bases its faith in absolute truths, then we'll know what it will reach our ears from the outset the strength of prejudice. And that is precisely what happens with Garaudy's work: from start to finish its author seeks to present and defend the doctrine as the only possible reading frames, valid and irrevocable ways to position themselves against the world, and consequently the reading Sartre's done here is more relevant to an accusation that a thorough study. He always mentions it to label it, is rarely taken into account its other publications, and although accept some of his arguments, it is always seen in a spirit of demagogy. So much so, in my opinion, the nickname "magician" who mistakenly gives Garaudy Sartre describes his own work better as a critic.

are six parts that make up this Questions to Jean-Paul Sartre , all aimed at showing how the notions of dialectics, art, class and others, managed within the Sartrean theory cease to be a Marxist, even if intended as a complement of Marxism, and this because, as Garaudy, bordering dangerously with idealism and abstraction characteristic of bourgeois thought. In short, the text contains a partial scan suggestive moments, though, that shows some aspects of disagreement between Sartre and Marxist, made by a spokesman of the latter and, like many of the works of its kind, it lacks the necessary breadth and clarity.

The book presents a fairly logical order as part of the primary considerations of life and matter to reach the most advanced disputes on historical materialism and revolution. Then try to clean out some of the ideas presented there to organize a dialogue covering both voice and Garaudy Sartre as my own on the subject of some discussion on which I believe have sustainable positions.

The problem of the relationship Marxism-existentialism

Garaudy asks if he can be considered a form of existentialism deepening of Marxism or, conversely, a radical opposition to it. However, although many of us would like to know the answer to this question only once we together for a presentation of the problem judiciously, it happens that in principle Garaudy has already given us his opinion, and not only that, but it has also started his long adjectives inventory against Sartre: ignorant, contradictory, ambiguous, religious. The author is delighted with his own rant and spends more of ink in the defense of the party in the debate on the issues you want to discuss. This undermines the seriousness to his study, as its answer to the question, that is, it is impossible to reconcile existentialism and Marxism, is not acting the way of thesis work, but in the form of a bias to defend.

Thus, although both authors share some views on politics and philosophy, and in the presentation of the book you can find the main point of divergence between Sartre and Garaudy, the possibility of a relationship between Marxism and existentialism. While for the former is not just about a possible link, but above all necessary, for the second, the realization of these two worlds in a theory involves an investment of the fundamentals of Marxism, since they place in materialism and class privilege would become the conscience and the individual.

Obviously there are other points of disagreement, for example, with respect to the alleged "pessimism" of Jean-Paul Sartre, or lack of commitment to the ideals of the Communist Party, but the principle of these differences also comes from reality itself: Sartre is an existentialist and a socialist Garaudy stubborn. Garaudy even Sartre's position, much like that of a sickness is a consequence of its distance from the party, so clear in stating "There are people who call themselves leftists, but from the moment you refuse to cooperate with the Communist Party (...) are condemned to impotence."

In other words, Garaudy not have a form of resistance other than in connection with leftist political organizations, even if this involves a similar reification which aims to combat. This controversy, which had one of its most vibrant chapters in clashes between George Lukacs and Rosa Luxemburg (1), allowed here show the two reference fields from Sartre and Garaudy speaking: the individual as a producer of what exists through the processes of consciousness, and materialism historical is the basis of any process of awareness, respectively.

Sartre believes that contemporary Marxism has two distinctive features: 1. the elimination of individual characteristics, and 2. conception of man as a passive organ. This scenario, or close to the ideological practices of the parties of his day, can only be overcome, in their view, creating a link between existentialist thought, who had worked closely in his early work, and an update of the Marxist theories society. In this regard, Critique of Dialectical Reason suggests three main connectors: the psychoanalysis (given their input on ways to push the guy in the class), the sociology (focusing on the problem of social micromedia reveal power relations) and the phenomenology (in all matters concerning the purpose and aggregation of human actions).

Garaudy goes without saying that these lines of connection, but can contribute to studies of the Marxists, belong to a nature that differs in many aspects of the budgets of historical materialism. For this reason, his book reviews too fast for them and conform to disqualify to focus on a test that purports to reveal the inconsistencies of Sartre's thought. Here will respect the order of their work to show the kind of criticisms that Sartre and the manner in which his book is loaded, gradually, offensive language,

1. Existence and matter

There is no other way of knowing the world but through awareness and for this reason, knowledge and experience are processes that must always be studied first, as individual productions. Up to this point Sartre shares the view of almost all the rationalists, however, making particular interpretation of the processes of consciousness is to add the character of intent Ie give them a teleological level, based on phenomenological theories, says that understanding the world is only possible from the aggregation of the individual making the aims and actions taken to achieve them.

Even in the case of those holding called social consciousness for Sartre underlying all is a aggregation of individual conscience that produce, at the same time under similar historical and material conditions, some form of be in the world. But Sartre's position is more radical than it seems, since for him not only the knowledge , but also the existence own abroad is the result of individual conscience. Otherwise, what I know as well that there is nothing more than a human production and, consequently, the matter has no more reality than that warranted by our conscience. After this look

Sartre, Garaudy not sensed anything but a subjective idealism, because it breaks with the possibilities of existence to free beings of meaning or, rather, because, if accepted, proclaims "I can not say anything about the matter was of 'experience' I have of her, "and while this is true, it is a truism, says Garaudy, it is difficult accept the fact that the subject has no other form of existence than the conscious. To prove their critics, Garaudy brings up the early stages of evolution, as well as some important advances in modern science, with which it is possible to prove that the subject has a rhythm and independent movement, enough to claim to have a particular form to be different from the thought.

There is a counter-argument that Sartre is not given much importance in the book, which, however, is quite illuminating on the problem suggests the existence of matter. In his view, the matter would have a kind of dual nature: first, free of meaning, would inevitably exist in the absence of men as an inoperable, Sartre will not want to deal with it logically became one of the elements that we discussed the Marxists. But on the other hand, we found that the substance has a nature that results from everyday practice, that is, that it appears to be "an inexhaustible reservoir of experience" thinking about it, the phenomenologist, Sartre says, "our theory of the phenomenon has replaced the reality of the thing in the objectivity of the phenomenon, and it is founded on the use of infinity. "

willed not to see beyond what is stated in Critical of Dialectical Reason, Garaudy can not conceive that the nature of matter is concentrated in the praxis of men. For him, true defender of historical materialism, there must necessarily enduring material existence in time, which proves that, in addition to outdoor conditions promoted by humanity, is an independent development of matter, therefore, watch climate or geography were crucial to the development of history, these elements not only preceded the man in terms of existence, which show a way of being different from the conscious, but also shaped the human form of knowing and experience the world.

Unfortunately, as I reiterate, the desire to Garaudy to dismiss the "idealism" of Sartre him to ignore a number of situations: first, that since the late thirties and Sartre had been working with this idea, holding mainly in the phenomenology Husserl. At the time of Being and Nothingness , for example, had developed a deep lecture in which showed the way in which anything , that is, free stuff for current awareness, there was nothing but a there delayed or, if preferred, a contingency. At any time, according to chance or practice that requires it, the man brings the nothing, waiting, the stuff that remains in silence and anonymity. Hence it is clear that Sartre does not believe in non-matter, or non-existence of matter, but rather on an existence outdated by consciousness.

Similarly, Garaudy committed a procedural error by linking the theories of Marx and Sartre in a historical syncretism. This may not be relevant to an idealist, and therefore he insists, but for a Marxist who recognizes the man as a product of particular historical social system and, therefore, comparable only to another at a nominal value. Garaudy Sartre demands refer to history for clues about their abstractions, but he it is lost in the most unfair of all: the belief that Sartre, despite living hundreds of years of Marx, can not change their approach to the field or gymnastics, even when social conditions demand it, for the simple fact that Marx interpreted in any way.

This problem is particularly noticeable about Garaudy's critique of the notion of identity in Sartre. At first, promptly condemned it to behave as a theologian who transposes into an ideal time notions as freedom, conscience and experience, and later, not realizing that their work covers a particular line syncretic, it becomes to condemn for not realizing that, as Marx said, history of men always retains an essence evidenced: the struggle between classes. Garaudy is more contradictory to ensure that the identity postulate "what is" has changed radically in our times to force us to say "what is, becomes" but not by stealth to realize that becoming is precisely the concept of phenomenology, and that the axiom of evolution does not work for the approach of Marx, looking for every way to locate essential continuity.

2. Dialectical materialism

The problem of the dialectic Sartre proposed can be reduced, as Garaudy believes, as a syllogism:

"- only where there is dialectic aggregation purpose;
- The purpose is itself totalizing human
- Then, there are only words with the man and not There dialectics of nature "(p. 67)
This view would contrast with the classical Marxist interpretation, to which the dialectic is not the result of a uniquely human, but a dynamic movement between material nature and human consciousness. We are facing a cardinal point of the Marxist critique Sartre made basically because it is the place where they can best observed the consequences of historical materialism on the one hand, and individualism aware, on the other. Clearly, for Marxists, the motor of history can not only be a dialectic between man (and, more specifically, the class) and nature (material condition). In contrast, for existentialism, the possibility of a dialectic is entirely within humanity itself, given that consciousness is the basic form of knowledge, and the only matter at hand that there is one that has passed through the conscious operation .

What Garaudy can not understand is the fact that Sartre raising a positive reason, which would correspond to the sciences y la materia per se, y otra razón propiamente dialéctica en lo más alto de las acciones humanas. En su ceguera, Garaudy no comprende que una vez abordado el camino de la conciencia individualizada, la dialéctica, al modo en que tradicionalmente la estudian los marxistas, transforma su asidero material por una fenomenológico. Si para el marxismo la relación entre la estructura económica de una sociedad y el posicionamiento de sus clases frente al marco de producción que plantea son los elementos claves del análisis, para Sartre la dialéctica sólo puede promoverse a partir de la relación entre las totalizaciones que hace cada hombre del medio en el que vive o, en otras palabras, a partir del dialectical nominalism (the aggregation of specific totalizations operated by a multiplicity of specific singularities.)

Garaudy says Sartre not find a way to move from individuality to the notion of class, but this is a false problem. First, if Sartre renounces a dialectic of nature is because he is convinced that human history is the only manmade, the other as a natural and arbitrary, is simply the law of history, not its dialectical condition , which can only be one that we ourselves have put in so much thinking. So much so that Sartre suggests the transition from individual to the social fabric from projects reify specific mutually. Otherwise, if a certain social class takes strength and existence within a society because, in essence, the individuals that are experiencing the practical state of alienation and similar awareness.

Of course, it rains on this idea a new barrage of accusations: the story can actually be explained as a summation of individual totalizations? What role does not matter worked into the formation of social groups and processes of alienation and reification? Immersed in reading the Critique , and unwilling to give up historical materialism as Marx and Engels taught it, Garaudy commits a further error and Sartre is awarded the title of anti- Capital, and all for a very simple fact: while Marx noted that relations within a society are not encounters between individuals but between workers and capitalists, landlords and owners, etc., that is, between more or less established identity that subsumes the man inside, for Sartre, the social role is a state that derives from the aggregation of my experience, but no data a priori. Garaudy not see it that way, perhaps because they did not read the lines written by Sartre elsewhere:

"The intellectual is thus a man who becomes conscious of the opposition it and society, between the pursuit of practical truth (with all the rules that it implies) and the dominant ideology (with its traditional value system). This awareness, although it must, to be true, operated in the first the intellectual level of their professional activities and their role is not simply the revelation of the fundamental contradictions of society, ie class conflict, and within the ruling class itself, a conflict exists between the truth that it claims as its firm and myths, values \u200b\u200band traditions it maintains, and those who want to infect the other classes to ensure hegemony. Product torn societies, intellectual testifies about them because he has internalized his tear. It is thus a historical product. In this sense no society can complain about their intellectual, not accuse herself, since they have only those who have made "(2) Sartre
taken here the example of the intellectual: this man has internalized to make itself a whole way of position in the world, that is their immediate, individual experience, but there always comes a moment when he realizes that his own condition is also that of other individuals who share with him the same objective reality, hence it can take the class consciousness necessary to move further up to discover the structure of the society in which they live. A process that moves from the individual to the group, and from there to the historical structural dynamics, and shows that Sartre designed an alternative approach to Marxism and class struggle, other than that outlined by communism and its hackneyed mass of consciousness.

3. Aggregation and social revolution

Is not transform the world, asks with mock surprise Garaudy in the last chapter of his Questions to Jean-Paul Sartre . No one has said otherwise, but he wants to worry with them to deliver a sarcastic spirit. Share Marx and Sartre says Garaudy, the fact of placing the denial as the starting point of any social transformation, however, maintains that only Marx, when he thought that the end of capitalism would lead to the advent of classless society beyond the state denial of reality from which any revolution is brewing.

We agree that Marx said this pretty well, and that beyond the contradictions raised by the case of the USSR, China or even Cuba, this remains a possible issue. But Garaudy forget that Sartre is not replicated in denial, and in many of his writings was the way that Marxism was presented as an insurmountable ideology because, although different in their ornaments, the capitalist system at the time still had the same practices of exploitation of man by man (3). In these texts came to express true socialist fervor that his contemporaries often confused with objective reality with unsurpassed dynamics, which eventually had resulted in the internalization of certain practices as normal playback.

The story, headed by singers like Garaudy, not done by digesting the contents of the first works of Sartre, why persist in pigeonholing as a philosopher negative and contradictory. But the truth is that without ideological debts as strong as those of the orthodox Communists, Sartre was able to draw a new horizon for the class struggle and, above all, a very original interpretation of alienation and dialectics. "It is impossible to exist in the midst of men, they become objects for me and them for me without me being subject to them," said the first volume of his Critique of Dialectical Reason , and another proposition difficult to reach the depth of it that shows how alienation, for example, always understood in class practices for Sartre was at the same time in any action by individuals and even within the same processes of awareness of reality.

If Sartre had not believed in the transformation of social structures remained the primary purpose of the political left, since then never been mobilized by their friends in Mali and Algeria, nor had denounced Stalin's despotism nor had written Les Temps Modernes ; simply would have sat in his office to devour crime novels. But it happens that Garaudy, as seen at the beginning, everything outside the ranks of the party is necessarily an act of helplessness and lack of relevance of the ideas of Marxism. ________________________


Roger Garaudy raises his voice in protest against the Marxist Sartre: "This man has invested terms Capital, and its position dangerously dragging us into the abyss of negativity and idealism." In response, Sartre revalued the molds in which they are locked his contemporaries, as the deification of Marx has always been the main drawback of the left, and perhaps the most serious reason for his deterioration.

NOTES:

(1) The book Marxist Theory of Political Party 2: Organizational Issues includes many of the documents most important of this controversy, and evaluated together with the theories of Marx and Lenin concerning the role of the Communist Party in the organization of the proletarian masses.

(2) This text belongs to several lectures by Sartre in Japan during 1965 and later collected in volume VIII of Situations, entitled The Defense Intellectuals. The note is taken of
Sartre, Jean-Paul (1973) About 68 (location VIII) Argentina: Losada Ed. p. 303.

(3) In Araraquara Conference in Brazil in the same year publicación of the C rítica of Dialectica Razón, there lo que pueda detrimento of exponas Garaudy expresaba Sartre: "Any philosophy that does not start from reality, packaging materials and packaging technology, any philosophy does not take as its starting point the whole man and that does not odre Marx, Marxist philosophy is necessarily a retrograde today. " Tomado from Sartre, Jean-Paul (1987) Sartre en el Brasil: La Conferencia de Araraquara. Bogotá: Oveja Negra Ed. p. 20 .

0 comments:

Post a Comment