Jean-Paul Sartre - Reflections on the Jewish Question
Sunday, September 5, 2010
Films Joe D'amato On Line
AUTHOR: Jean-Paul Sartre
TITLE: Reflections on the Jewish Question
EDITORIAL: Sudamericana, SA (First Edition)
YEAR: 1988
PAGES: 140
TRANSLATION: Joseph Bianco
TITLE: Reflections on the Jewish Question
EDITORIAL: Sudamericana, SA (First Edition)
YEAR: 1988
PAGES: 140
TRANSLATION: Joseph Bianco
RANK: 9 / 10
Although there are several decades that separate us from the Second World War, and anti-Semitic propaganda has decreased considerably We are still far from overcoming the prejudice against Jews countries without assimilation policies, lack of socio-cultural awareness, and survival of intolerant speeches are some of the factors that keep the Semitic people faced the problem of identity . In other words, although there has been no movement since Hitler global annihilation against the Jews, the world has witnessed the diversification of their problems in perspective such as demographic, legal, moral so forth.For Alejandro Jiménez
currently , draw up an inventory of the books written about the subject would be a long effort, but one thing is clear, is that Reflections on the Jewish Question -text by Jean-Paul Sartre in 1946 - , occupies an important place there, not only remain in force within that ever expanding panorama of authors, titles and deeds, but above all because the original approach is proposed where you look at it: it mixed Sartre's existentialism phenomenological essays with their own Marxist political theory, an interpretation that has three basic references, namely anti-Semitism, the Jewish condition and policy improvement.
Sartre, who during his stay in 1933 in Berlin, knew how they took shape anti-Semitic practices of the Nazi Party, wrote this document for two purposes: First, define anti-Semitism as a phenomenon that involves the denial of ethnic specificity, ie the right of an imperialist discourse in Second, promoting the politicization of the Jews, in the sense that they can prove themselves the historical conditions under which they must operate their struggle for liberation. "Anti-Semitism is a Jewish problem," says the French philosopher, "is our problem because we are guilty and we also run the risk of being victims."
So Reflections on the Jewish Question is a book that departs radically from the description that characterized many works of its kind, on the contrary, what prevails here is an analysis of the situation, that is, examining the structure to created and maintains the discrimination and violence against the Jewish anti-Semite. The innovative aspect of Sartre's gaze becomes its main thesis: "Contrary to popular opinion, the Jewish character does not cause anti-Semitism but, conversely, is the anti-Semite who creates the Jew. The first phenomenon is anti-Semitism, social structure down and pre-logical worldview. "
The text is divided into four parts: the first is a study on the status of anti-Semitic (in which you base your position, what representations has the Jew, and what consequences follow from the actions performed); in the second and fourth parts, Sartre observes the ways of overcoming anti-Semitism, unfortunate considering all those who wish to rescue the Jewish man, and not vice versa, as with the doctrine of liberalism. Finally, the third part examines some of the traits that historically attributed to the Jew (race, religion, nature, money, and so on), most of them anti-Semitic superstería product.
Through a language that never leaves the complexity of dealing with the author on each page reveals a new aspect, that "inquiring intelligence" that characterizes his works, reaches here a lucid without Background: frank, ironic and critical, Jean-Paul Sartre and comes from the whole situation, the individual to the group, the problem to the result, and every word can be considered a true statement of the company. Then reorganizes the contents of the text through the three dimensions mentioned earlier: the anti-Semite, the Jew, and the improvement process.
The
Semitic "If a man wholly or partially attributed the misfortunes of his country and his own misfortunes to the presence of Jewish elements in the community where you live, if it intends to remedy this state of affairs by depriving some Jews their rights or in deviation from some social and economic functions of the territory or expelling or exterminating them all, is said to have Semitic opinions "(p. 9)Anti-Semitism, so defined, it reveals its particular feature, according to Sartre, is the allocation of a set of social and cultural problems of Jewish existence. To argue this view, which is in principle the objectification of the Jews, the anti-Semitic appeals to arguments that have little to do with reason, and instead reveal a pre-logical and mystical conception of the universe. In fact, when asked to substantiate an anti-Semite ideology, he draws on two main roads: the history or social data, but in both cases, the hard fact that could serve as backup to his thoughts, there prevails a passionate representation of the Jew.
For example, a woman says: "I have had disputes with the fur unbearable, I have stolen, burned skin I trusted them, as well: they were all Jews." This anti-Semitic view that considers the issue is an argument for their hatred, but what has led her to decide to hate the Jews and not to fur? To the Jews as a group, not the Jew in particular that could deceive? The answer is: there is a predisposition to try traditional Jews. Under this dynamic, all historical and social arguments that can provide anti-Semites, are borne on a strict interpretation of Jewish, speak from the prejudice that over time has led to the contempt for "Jewish" and that they are constantly updated.
This quality of anti-Semitism led Sartre to claim that the phenomenon deviates substantially from a thought to correspond better with a passion : seems to have a rational basis, but it actually hides a projection of the spirit. Moreover, to the extent it is a passionate point of order, leading to anti-Semitic to stay ahead of the facts which might make him desist from his position to feed them their interpretation, "has chosen to live in the passionate tone." The Jew, the anti-Semitic, has no distinct existence to which he attributes is his creation, his scapegoat.
But for this interpretation of the Jews to work is needed to unify two elements: first, the idea of \u200b\u200ba mythical organization of the world and, secondly, the justification for their hatred by a Manichean view. According to the anti-Semitic, and this was one of the main lines of Nazi ideology, is a special relationship that links their culture, which is constructed as heir to his knowledge, his strength and, in general, its values, he acts on a pride that comes from being the son of French, or German, had acquired a "property" not could buy any Jew. While the latter will never cease to be an outsider, the anti-Semitic enjoying the benefits provided by your "race", nationality.
Therefore, establishing a framework that distinguishes perfectly to the anti-Semitic Jews based on their axiological qualities. All that belongs to the country's cultural heritage will be considered positive, and everything that comes from the Jews, magically imbued his "nature", will be the opposite. Unable to provide rational explanations for their hatred, uses anti-Semitic belief that there was an initial state (mythical) of purity and benevolence, which was disrupted thanks to the arrival of outsiders. Accordingly, it intends to restore the primordial, excluding or exterminating the Jews have access to their culture. There
Semitic formulas for reconciliation: the Jew can not give up their status, the status that he has imposed: everything he does or says makes his mark, and as it moves away from interest homogenizer restituyente and should be avoided. Therefore, the anti-Semite is an expert in waterproofing, crouched in his passion, the conviction of being a hero, even, of being a victim of the Jews, not troubled by the violence that could spark, any act of discrimination, whether it results in death or exile, is justified, since the Jew is an intruder who threatens their security, "the more (is) given to fighting evil, the less tempted (is) to make good on questioned. "
So, Sartre thinks, it's fun to be anti-Semitic. The Jew, although French or German, is still second-class citizens and, therefore, easy victim of their actions. The fundamentalism that underlies his passion blind to the reasons that might show that the Jew is also working for their country and in all respects is to be like the others. Not because his reasons are strong so the anti-Semitic remains undisturbed, it is because he believes only it has the right to judge. Pretending to be targeted by Jews, justified his pride and fight, pointing to an unbridgeable distance, since, regardless of the economic power they can get to have the Jews, there are values \u200b\u200bthat are the prerogative and must defend.
However, and this was one of the many lies of Nazism, anti-Semitism does not imply a political struggle, Sartre defined as a stream of passion that draws the most gullible and obviously do not want to transform the state of things, but to restore a previous order. In addition, anti-Semitism anywhere, you can find a reference to the class struggle, a concept necessary to any processing, and this is because the anti-Semite is a unit, first, of him with his country and then the Jew by his actions, spaces that cast everyone in perfectly predictable possibilities.
Thus, giving of metaphysical principles to all sides-the anti-Semitic show that the Jew has a natural inclination to evil (greed, to envy, to introspection) and download it its force sometimes pushes the limits of sadism, verbigracia those sexual behaviors that let you tell the Jewish superiority, his ability to intimidate, mastery and pleasure. The portrait, then, is the anti-Semitic, and that includes him who is by inaction, or silence, is expressed in the words of Sartre, as follows:
"is a man who is afraid. No Jews, by the way: of himself, of his conscience, his freedom, their instincts, their responsibilities, loneliness, change, society and the world, of everything except the Jews. He is a coward that does not confess his cowardice, a murderer and censorship which represses its tendency to murder without being able to curb it and that, however, does not dare to kill but in effigy or in the anonymity of a crowd, a malcontent who does not dare to rebel for fear of the consequences of their rebellion. Adhering to anti-Semitism, it takes just one opinion is chosen himself as a person. Choose the permanence and the impenetrability of the stone, the total irresponsibility of the warrior who listens to her bosses, and has no boss. Choose not to buy anything, do not deserve anything, but everything is given birth, and is not noble. Choose, finally, that the Well is a fait accompli, beyond question, beyond reach and does not dare to contemplate for fear of being taken to discuss and have to look elsewhere. The Jew is for him an excuse: in other countries, use the black, in others yellow. The existence of the Jewish embryo can simply drown in their distress, convinced that their position was always pointed in the world, that this position was expected and he has, by tradition, the right to occupy "(p. 49)The Jewish
common forms are permeated define the Jewish anti-Semitic speech. If you are looking accurate as of the race, you run the risk of deducting physical features, are essential; if you prefer from the description of his religion, then it must be borne in mind that this is just a symbolic means, as their beliefs have not been able to fight the "attack conjugate of rationalism and the Christian spirit." Total, which, contrary to what anti-Semites are saying the Jews do not form a unity or racial or religious community. If there is anything that can be seen as common to the Jews is, rather, its situation, living in the midst of a community that considers Jews.
Sartre
This look allows you to hold the idea that the Jew is above all an invention of anti-Semitic. "It is no exaggeration to say he writes, which are Christians who have created the Jew to lead to a sudden halt in their uptake and provide it, in spite of itself, a function which has excelled in later. " Stated another way, having allowed for full integration of Jews in the national life of the countries, not having been relegated to social functions, of which continue today specialists, then the Jew would not be seen as a problem but as an important part of society [1].
If the Jew is a man whom the other designated as such, holding a social structure that allows it, we must abandon the idea of \u200b\u200bseeking their nature, and devote ourselves to the consideration of the elements that contextualize the situation: this is the method of Sartre. In this regard it should be noted a first feature, and that has to do with social class they belong to the Jews because, as the anti-Semites are also mostly in small and middle bourgeoisie, not the working class - composed of the country's poorest sectors, "nor in the exclusive social stratum that are the owners of the means of production.
Furthermore, the Jew is not a simple average bourgeois, but a man whose job depends largely on the reputation, which, paradoxically, is twofold: itself of its work, and that comes from their Jewishness. May be good or bad in what I do, an excellent lawyer, for example, but society will always be there to remind her condition: a mistake, a sin, and even the same virtues, are Jewish, and contribute to the reaffirmation of prejudices about him weave his countrymen. Thus, it is operating on implicit or explicit, processes of commodification, is to admire him or judge him, always will be the subject of the trial of the other, a fact that contributes to the character that even close, never quite belong ends: himself as Jewish. It
follows that the Jews have a particular form of participation in society: on the one hand, fully enjoy the economic benefits to be derived from it, but, on the other, are strictly isolated from the socio-cultural values \u200b\u200band idiosyncratic country in which they live. This really puts them in a situation even less advantageous than the worker, who as German or French, at least can be considered the heir of those values, but they, the Jews, inhabitants of a land that were continually repeats are foreigners, they are trying in vain to be treated, always have to feel excluded.
However, Jean-Paul Sartre sets At this point a split: on one hand places the Jews inauthentic, all of them lack the awareness of their condition and, therefore, elusive creatures, and on the other hand, Jews authentic, that is, those living up to their status as Jews. Roughly, the former want to be accepted as men in society, showing the common elements that make the others so ashamed of what they are like Jews, desperately seeking a rationale that all those who may reject them. For its part, the Jews authentic look at the structure that determines identity and foster a process which necessarily come off the rebellion.
Sartre studied a series of characteristic features of the inauthentic Jew, in order to avoid confusion, it should be understood as the product of anti-Semitic:
1. The Jew is introspective: is a logical consequence of anti-Semitic remarks, the Jew is fear that their actions conform to the representation of them by society. Opera here a superdeterminación from the very heart of the Jew who only reaffirms their identity. That is, the desire to test himself abroad and is not as it forces him to live is often lost in thought, examining, marking and fighting its flaws, and not simply in it, but all Jews from their ghetto, which can not be separated from their immediate reality. It is cautious because evil plan alive: it is because it has to be instigated.
2. The Jew is reasoning, but here too there is no vice of greed, the Jew does not live plotting against the other plans: it is reasonable since it has been found in the abstract universal space where it is equal to other men; there it is possible his blunt, the departure of his being a Jew to approach a human nature to create shared with others, even with their own anti-Semitic. It is therefore another way of Jewish evasion against the subjugation of their daily lives.
3. The Jew is uncreative : This allocation goes without, if the Jew is not a creator, then where we left the contributions of Kafka, Proust, or Einstein, what happens, simply, is that creativity Jewish focuses on the level of rationality is not the concrete work, a fact that is perceived as failing by the anti-Semitic.
4. The Jew has a characteristic appearance : but perhaps that community does not possess? What happens is that the Aryan has captured the value of the body, establishing itself as a paradigm. A swollen nose does not determine in any way a moral quality, however the anti-Semite, it becomes a tool to poison the innermost feelings of the Jew, the dam received daily trials, you experience behavior ashamed of himself.
5. The Jew has no touch : another estimable consequence of its rationalism, as if the Jew is an essentially inauthentic, little can understand the impact they have on the relations of men's passions, instincts, and ritual, it can never discover the deep meaning with these things when communicating.
6. The Jewish especially appreciated money, but same thing happens with everything else, if the Jew money in a special attraction, only because it is an abstract element, that is, something he shares with another man, regardless of whether Jewish or not, a sort of universal connection, if any-way property-nothing can separate myth and society that uses it daily to regulate their functions.
7. The Jew is restless : something that can not be otherwise and shares with blacks, gypsies, or any other community excluded, the uncertainty about his tenure, contingency, forces him to recognize the powers at the time least expected it to finally banish his country. Contrary to what might inferred, is not a metaphysical anxiety which you experience, not religious, is a concern that comes from social status.
Semitism Ways of overcoming
These seven features [2], should be reiterated, characterize the inauthentic Jew or otherwise, is the image that has built the Jewish anti-Semite, and that traditionally the subject determined as . They are all inventions ideological anti-Semitism, none could serve to define, but for a way to deny the true condition of the Jews. However, it is also what accounts for its objective reality, since, beyond that this not be compared with the other they may be, are the conditions as set out in the plane of existence, and only of its acceptance, to live fully the situation, you may find an alternative to overcome.
Thus, we are facing a crucial definition of the problem. Sartre wants to emphasize several things: first, that what historically has been called the Jewish question , is above all an anti-Semitic issue: if the latter is the creator of the Jew, then the problem of racist violence is something that should solve the anti-Semite and the Jew is a simple receiver. But as it is clear that self-Semitic not undertake a solution must be sought a different alternative starting point to the drawbacks noted. In general terms the ways of overcoming anti-Semitism can come from:
1. The democratic liberalism, but this is a useless defender considers Sartre. Located in a universalist position similar to that assumes the inauthentic Jew, "the Democrat is satisfied by appeal to the liberation of the Jew as a man," wants to destroy him as a Jew for not keeping it but man, subject abstract and universal rights of man and citizen. " If it stands, it is because it creates in the Jew is because he wants to show that there is a man under the "shell". You have the right as all-Democrat say at the height of his defense, not because it is Jewish, but because he is a man.
2. The authentic Jew : may be the quickest solution to the Jewish problem comes precisely from the bosom of the Jews, but here is faced with a dilemma: either looking for the consolidation of a nation state centered in Israel, which imply a new mass mobilization around the world, or else, we appeal to the claim of the Jewish condition in the various countries where a Jew can live, decision leading to arrange multiple movements of resistance and politicization permanent campaigns, as well as the inevitable encounter, in every place, with far-right conservative ideologies [3].
3. The assimilation : Sartre suggests the third possibility to be opening a solution, making it very clear they mean by assimilation, not integration of the Jew as man, but precisely as a Jew. No society can consider the price to pay for the assimilation of the Jews is the annihilation of their identity, rather, its relationship to the paradigm-Semitic. According to Sartre, the Jew, as construction historical disappear, the way of social classes, only through the advent of the socialist utopia. In this state, when no longer fit place to annihilate the enemies who intend to human potentialities, the Jew will have found a space for their ultimate realization. Hence, the author's words:
"In societies where women are not asked to rate the voters to change their sex as they approach the ballot box: the voice of women is worth exactly like the man, but rate as women, with their passions and concerns of women, as women. When it comes to legal rights and rights of the Jew even darker, but also essential, which are not written in any code, it is not as long as there in the Jewish Christian possible that such rights must be afforded, but as a French Jew is: we must accept it with his character, habits, tastes, religion if religion is your name, physical features. And this acceptance, if full and frank, the Jew first facilitate the election of its authenticity and then gradually make it possible without violence, by the very course of history, this assimilation to which they want to force "(p. 134)As concrete ways towards this goal Sartre offers an education that is not based on traditional concepts of disrepute was the Jew, the prohibition of laws that run counter to the defense as a citizen and, finally, changing the circumstances under which, generally, is chosen to be anti-Semitic, because, although we can not prohibit the freedom to choose to be, "says Sartre," Soper to go counter to the foundation of man is precisely the choice, at least if we can do a bit in terms of the circumstances under which makes the election: politics, social structures, etc., will play in this regard a decisive role.
Anyway, one thing not to be missed of view: the Jewish problem is the Jew, is not, nor is unique to the anti-Semitic, is a question whose responsibilities are shared. If in the past many of us could become the executioners of the Jews because of our silence and indolence, history has again reversed a commitment that we can not escape: They define our own status, because while one of the men, be it black, Jewish or whatever, is kept under the yoke of discriminatory policies, not be declared human liberation, of luck, which still has much to do. __________________
basic tool for discussion, Reflections on the Jewish Question, is an application of Sartre's thought to be an insurmountable problem yet, and against which human wisdom will pronounce its verdict soon.
NOTES:
[1] Sartre states about the prevalence of Jews in trade and economic charges that "the church of the Middle Ages has tolerated the Jews, as it had been assimilated by force or ransom, because they filled a staple economic function: damn, damn exercised a trade, but indispensable, can not own land or serve in the army (and who were not citizens of the country) practiced the trade of money that a Christian could not be addressed without staining. So the Christian curse soon redoubled an economic curse and is primarily the latter that has persisted. Today reproach the Jews to exercise unproductive trades without realizing that their apparent autonomy within the nation from the beginning that they were stationed in these offices, vedándoles all others. " See pp. 63 et seq.
[2] These traits inferred from my reading, are not listed literally by Sartre in his essay.
[3] Even today the Romanian Roma are victims of discrimination policies France. They shared with Jews the harshness of the Nazi holocaust, and as they have been confronted with the problem of identity status, subjugation, discrimination, vulnerability. Nothing says, then, that the awareness of being Jewish, or Gypsy, can mean a lot when it comes to minorities who must contend with complex machinery of power and intimidation. Sarkozy is one of the many spokesmen for racial and cultural intolerance.
Subscribe to entries
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment